Fighting Brock shouldn’t be that difficult. A Water Gun from a Squirtle or a Wine Whip from a Bulbasaur should be more than enough to take out both of its geodudes And His onyx. However, not every trainer started with Squirtle or Bulbasaur.
Trainers started with Charmander or Pikachu in the original pokemon red And Blue The Games were in trouble when it came to Brock. This difficulty curve is so bad and so undeniable that the anime adaptation ended up reflecting it perfectly. The only difference is that Ash had plot armor to help him in this fight. In a way, players of future Kanto-based games were also given a sort of plot armor. Brock is just that unreasonably tough, especially for an early game boss.
Brock’s early game difficulty can be attributed to his Rock-type Pokémon. In general, these types of Pokémon are easy to defeat because they have a lot of weaknesses. As long as the trainer has a Pokémon that can use water, grass, fight, or land attacks, they’ll be fine. Since Brock’s Rock types are also part of Ground, he can also be hit for super effective Ice-type damage.
For Trainers starting their journey from Pallet Town, however, there are almost no Pokémon that can use super effective attacks on Rock types. Most of the Pokémon catchable between Pallet Town and Peter City are Normal, Poison, Flying, and Bug types. These Pokémon not only lack the coverage to hit rock types for super effective damage, but most of their moves Oppose By them. This resistance, combined with the high defense stats of Geodude and Onyx, makes them more likely to beat all of a trainer’s Pokémon before they go down.
The issue is just as bad, if not worse, for Charmander and Pikachu. Not only are Charmander’s fire attacks resisted by Rock, but Pikachu’s electric attacks are completely ineffective due to secondary ground typing. Thus, in any dream the trainers have to use their ace against Brock’s ace to go up in smoke.
This difficulty spike was fully featured pokemon origin, In this series, Raid, who started with Charmander, needed all five of his Pokémon to take away Brock’s two Pokémon. Even his Nidoran with a double kick, a fighting attack, was quickly out. In the end, his Charmander won from scratch only because the rest of his Pokémon had turned Onyx’s hit points to red. That, and the Metapod’s string shot reduced its speed.
Battling Brock without Squirtle or Bulbasaur was also featured well through the original anime in Episode 5, “Showdown in Pewter City”. In this episode, Ash sends his Pikachu against Brock’s Onyx. Pikachu immediately signals Ash to use one of his other Pokémon. Electric Mouse was simply intimidated by the size of Pokémon Rock Snake, but if he had known what the real issue was, he could have hit Ash even harder.
Unfortunately, even if Pikachu successfully convinces Ash to switch Pokémon, it doesn’t make much difference. Ash’s only other Pokémon at the time were Pidgeto and Butterfree, both of which he caught in the Viridian Forest. Unfortunately, none of these Pokémon has an attack that can also deal neutral damage to Onyx.
Ash, though, could have been better off switching to Butterfree or Pidgeotto anyway. Again, Pikachu’s electric attacks couldn’t hurt Onyx either because it was part of the ground-type. All it could do was make Onyx useless as a used bind. Ash had no choice but to lose the match.
If Ash wanted to beat Brock, he couldn’t directly accuse him of being as amateurish as he was; He would need a strategy. According to the logic of the old games, their best course of action would have been to go back an old route and catch more Pokémon. He could have caught a Nidoran and leveled it until he learned the double kick. He could even capture a monkey and level it up until he was strong enough to fight Brock; Of course, since he was going to be a primap catcher in the future, this was not technically an option for him. If he had done any of these things, he could have easily defeated Brock.
Unfortunately, beating Brock like this posed many problems from a storytelling perspective. For one thing, it could have made victory easier, at least by the logic of the game, in what should have been an uphill battle. More importantly, the amount of time it would have taken Ash to find, capture, and train either Nidoran or the monkey would have been exhausting for both. And the audience. He needed a more immediate solution to keep the story moving while maintaining the tension.
Fortunately for Ash, the Plot armor in the form of Flint came to his aid. The rock seller came up with an idea that would allow Ash to charge Pikachu’s electricity to the limit so that even the land types would be hurt by it. Nothing like this would ever work in games, but, again, for plot progress, it worked for Ash.
Misty offers to help Ash by lending her a kind of water. This plot would have been armor as well, but at least it would have followed the rules of the games. The only reason Ash wanted to be with Pikachu was because he now had something to prove after Brock lost to Onyx. That’s why he didn’t get Squirtle or Bulbasaur early. For Ash’s victory to mean anything, it had to do with Pikachu.
Since Ashwater didn’t rely on Pokémon, he had to bring water through another layer of Plot Armor. While Pikachu’s electric attacks could eventually hurt Onyx, the Rock Snake Pokémon was still on the ropes with its bind. Fortunately, Pikachu’s Thunderbolt sets the gym on fire and sets off the sprinklers. Combining Pikachu’s electric attacks with water, Ash came close enough to winning that Brock gave him his Boulder Badge.
Ash didn’t do anything in anime that could never happen in games. Although, game Freak Gifted players with plot armor to defeat Brock. That way, even if they didn’t want Squirtle, Bulbasaur, Nidoran, or Monkey, they could still win with Charmander, Pikachu, or Eevee.
In pokemon firered And leaf greenCharmander’s Line Metal Claw, a new, super-effective steel-type move, can be learned at level 13. Similarly, in partners Pikachu and Eevee Pokemon: Let’s Go You can learn double kick at game level 12. These Pokémon can only learn these moves by leveling up in these games, which makes them feel like a casual means of progress. Eevee will never know how lucky it is.
Without this plot armor, however, Brock would be ridiculously difficult to beat. Between his placement in the game and the lack of Pokémon that he can handle, it’s almost guaranteed to be a long and difficult battle. If Ash and the other Trainers wanted to win without Squirtle or Bulbasaur, they needed some To help give them an edge. In the anime take pity on the baddies who now have to fight Forrest’s Reaper or Brock’s Mega Steelix.